| Year | Club | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Fa 21 | Columbus Crew | $230,000 |
| Fa 20 | Columbus Crew | $239,167 |
| Fa 19 | Columbus Crew | $199,166.75 |
| Fa 18 | Seattle Sounders FC | $196,041.67 |
| Fa 17 | Columbus Crew | $251,875 |
| Fa 16 | Columbus Crew | $200,000 |
| Fa 15 | Columbus Crew | $170,166.67 |
| Fa 14 | Columbus Crew | $153,875 |