| Year | Club | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Fa 25 | FC Dallas | $445,000 |
| Sp 25 | FC Dallas | $737,125 |
| Fa 24 | Colorado Rapids | $702,125 |
| Fa 23 | Colorado Rapids | $702,125 |
| Fa 22 | Colorado Rapids | $272,125 |
| Fa 21 | Colorado Rapids | $247,125 |
| Fa 20 | Colorado Rapids | $154,937 |
| Fa 19 | Colorado Rapids | $144,937.5 |
| Fa 18 | Columbus Crew | $75,750.04 |
| Fa 17 | Columbus Crew | $72,500.04 |