| Year | Club | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Fa 21 | Columbus Crew | $133,667 |
| Fa 20 | FC Cincinnati | $90,042 |
| Fa 19 | Seattle Sounders FC | $70,250.04 |
| Fa 18 | New York City FC | $120,230 |
| Fa 17 | Sporting Kansas City | $110,550 |
| Fa 16 | Sporting Kansas City | $76,750 |
| Fa 15 | Sporting Kansas City | $73,750 |