| Year | Club | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Fa 14 | Portland Timbers | $55,008 |
| Fa 13 | Columbus Crew | $175,000 |
| Fa 12 | Columbus Crew | $145,600 |
| Fa 11 | Columbus Crew | $133,500 |
| Fa 10 | Columbus Crew | $122,500 |
| Fa 09 | Columbus Crew | $102,500 |
| Fa 08 | Columbus Crew | $69,147.81 |
| Fa 07 | Columbus Crew | $56,331.25 |