| Year | Club | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Fa 14 | DC United | $235,500 |
| Fa 13 | Philadelphia Union | $216,500 |
| Fa 12 | Seattle Sounders FC | $185,325 |
| Fa 11 | Seattle Sounders FC | $136,500 |
| Fa 10 | Seattle Sounders FC | $99,999.96 |
| Fa 08 | New York Red Bulls | $58,737.5 |
| Fa 07 | New York Red Bulls | $48,500 |